If you want to spice up your fall makeup look a bit without trying something totally crazy, take a cue from Selena Gomez, whose look for The Tonight Show with Jay Leno was featured on Glamour magazine’s beauty blog.

Gomez had her usual thick black eyeliner and dark lashes, but instead of a boring eyeshadow, she chose a shiny, dewy shimmer that made her eyes look a bit dressy without being overly showy.

To get the look yourself, use a black eyeliner to line your inner rims and your upper lash line. Use two coats of a super volumizing mascara, like Rilastil – Makeup Volumizing Mascara, to get seriously sexy fringe. Then, choose a gray shimmery cream, like Jane Iredale – Eye Gloss, to get a glistening finish. Just rub it on your eyelids and a bit past your creases for a gorgeous glowing effect.

Whether you’re singing on national television like Gomez, or just prepping for a night out on the town, a surprising flash of glitter when you blink is sure to get you noticed.