Makeup remover is a key element in every girl’s nighttime beauty regimen. After all, you need to get off all the products you’ve used at the end of the day to let your skin breathe and prevent clogged pores, or worse – a breakout. However, there’s more to this product than meets the eye. It’s crucial to be mindful about what’s in the solution you’re using, as well as how you’re apply it to ensure it’s effective. Additionally, you could do some damage to your skin if you aren’t careful about which makeup remover you use.

So before you go to clear off your cosmetics, keep these tips in mind:

Read the label
Just as you look at the ingredients on your food to make sure it’s good for you, it’s imperative to do the same with your makeup remover. Certain agents can be particularly harsh, and therefore, should be avoided, especially if you have sensitive skin. Stay away from solutions that contain fragrances, preservatives or alcohol. None of these ingredients will make the remover work better, so they’re unnecessary. Plus, they can irritate the skin, particularly around the eye area.

Consider your skin type
You take your skin type into account when buying a cleanser and moisturizer, so keep this mind when you’re purchasing a makeup remover as well. Dr. David Bank, director and founder of The Center for Dermatology, Cosmetic & Laser Surgery, told The Huffington Post that it can be helpful to consult with your dermatologist if you’re unsure about your type or what product is ideal for your skin. As a general rule, though, he advised using a hypoallergenic fragrance-free makeup remover if you have rosacea or eczema. Sensitive skin types should reach for cream or liquid cleansers, which are less drying. For example, G.M. COLLIN’s hydrating Sensiderm Cleansing Milk, which has soothing properties, is made for sensitive skin.

Be gentle
The method that you use to remove your makeup is just as important as the product. Especially when you’re removing stubborn waterproof mascara or eyeliner, it can be tempting to rub vigorously to get it all off. This tactic is detrimental, though, as the eye area is particularly delicate. An optimal eye makeup remover will be strong enough to slough off any product, so let it do the work for you.

The best way to get rid of makeup without irritating your skin is to press a cotton ball or pad soaked with remover over your lids. The product will dissolve, and then you can simply wipe it away. Always avoid rubbing the under-eye area and follow up by washing your face to eliminate any residue from the remover.